The maritime industry has long relied on satellite communication systems to stay connected while traversing the vast and often remote expanses of the world’s oceans. Traditionally, Very Small Aperture Terminal (VSAT) technology has been the backbone of this connectivity, providing a vital link for ships at sea. However, the advent of Starlink, a cutting-edge satellite internet service developed by SpaceX, is transforming the landscape of maritime communication. As Starlink gains momentum, VSAT is increasingly seen as an outdated technology. This article explores the differences between Starlink and VSAT, the satellite orbits they rely on, and how these technologies are reshaping the maritime industry.

Starlink is a satellite internet constellation being constructed by SpaceX, designed to provide high-speed, low-latency internet access across the globe. Unlike traditional satellite internet systems, Starlink relies on a constellation of thousands of small satellites in Low Earth Orbit (LEO). These satellites work together to deliver continuous, high-bandwidth internet coverage, even in the most remote regions of the planet.

VSAT (Very Small Aperture Terminal) is a traditional satellite communication technology that has been in use for decades. VSAT systems use geostationary satellites to provide internet connectivity. These systems are characterized by small satellite dishes (typically ranging from 2.5 to 8 feet in diameter) to  that communicate with satellites in Geostationary Earth Orbit (GEO) or Medium Earth Orbit (MEO). VSAT has been the go-to solution for maritime communication due to its reliability and ability to provide consistent coverage over large areas.

LEO (Low Earth Orbit) satellites orbit the Earth at an altitude of approximately 100 to 1200 miles. Due to their proximity to Earth, LEO satellites have much lower latency (the delay between sending and receiving data) compared to satellites in higher orbits. This makes LEO systems ideal for real-time applications, such as video conferencing and online gaming. However, LEO satellites cover smaller areas, necessitating a large number of satellites to ensure global coverage. Starlink operates in LEO, utilizing thousands of satellites to provide seamless, low-latency internet access.

MEO (Medium Earth Orbit) satellites orbit the Earth at altitudes between 1,200 to 22,000 miles. MEO satellites offer a balance between coverage area and latency. They provide wider coverage than LEO satellites but with slightly higher latency. MEO systems are often used for navigation services, such as GPS, and some communication networks. While MEO satellites can be used in VSAT systems, they are less common than GEO satellites.

GEO (Geostationary Earth Orbit) satellites orbit the Earth at an altitude of approximately 23,000 miles. At this altitude, a satellite takes 24 hours to complete one orbit, matching the Earth’s rotation. This allows GEO satellites to remain stationary relative to a specific point on the Earth’s surface. GEO satellites provide continuous coverage to large areas, making them ideal for broadcasting and communication services. However, the high altitude results in significant latency, typically around 600 milliseconds or more. VSAT systems primarily rely on GEO satellites for their operations.

• Latency: 20-40 milliseconds (ms)
• Speed: 50 Mbps to 500 Mbps (potential for higher speeds as the network expands)

Starlink’s LEO constellation offers significantly lower latency than traditional satellite systems, making it well-suited for applications requiring real-time communication. The high speed of Starlink is another major advantage, enabling bandwidth-intensive activities such as video streaming, online gaming, and large data transfers.

• Latency: 600 ms or more (depending on the satellite’s orbit)
• Speed: 1 Mbps to 50 Mbps (higher speeds available at a higher cost)

VSAT systems, particularly those relying on GEO satellites, suffer from high latency due to the distance the signal must travel. While VSAT can deliver reliable connectivity, the higher latency can be a drawback for certain applications. Speed can vary depending on the service plan and the satellite’s capabilities, with higher speeds often coming at a premium.

Starlink’s LEO constellation is designed to provide global coverage, including remote and underserved regions. As the network expands, coverage will continue to improve, making it possible to stay connected even in the most isolated maritime locations. However, the availability of service may still be limited in some areas as the constellation is not yet fully deployed.

VSAT offers near-global coverage, especially with GEO satellites, which provide consistent service over large areas. VSAT is particularly strong in providing connectivity in established maritime routes and regions with significant shipping traffic. However, coverage can be less reliable in polar regions and other remote locations where satellite footprints may not overlap.

Starlink requires a compact satellite dish (often referred to as a “dishy”) and a user terminal. The equipment is designed to be easy to install and configure, even for non-experts. The dish automatically aligns with the best satellite in view, making it highly user-friendly. For maritime use, specialized Starlink maritime kits are available, which are designed to withstand harsh sea conditions.

VSAT systems require a larger satellite dish, often accompanied by complex equipment like modems and signal amplifiers. Installation typically requires professional expertise, particularly for maritime applications, where the dish must be carefully aligned to maintain a stable connection. The equipment is more robust but also more cumbersome, and installation costs can be significant.

• Equipment Cost: $599 to $2,500 (depending on the kit)
• Service Cost: $200 to $5,000 per month (depending on data plan and usage)

Starlink offers competitive pricing, especially considering its high speed and low latency. The cost of the service varies depending on the plan, with maritime-specific plans generally priced higher due to the specialized equipment and coverage.

• Equipment Cost: $10,000 to $50,000 (depending on the system)
• Service Cost: $500 to $25,000 per month (depending on bandwidth and usage)

VSAT systems are typically more expensive, both in terms of equipment and service costs. Maritime VSAT plans can be particularly costly, especially for vessels requiring high bandwidth. However, the reliability and established infrastructure of VSAT can justify the expense for certain users.

• Low latency and high-speed internet access
• Relatively low equipment and service costs
• Easy installation and user-friendly setup
• Expanding global coverage, including remote areas

• Service availability may be limited in some regions as the network is still being deployed
• Potential service interruptions during the satellite constellation build-out
• Maritime-specific equipment is still evolving and may not be as robust as traditional systems

• Established and reliable technology with global coverage
• Consistent service in traditional maritime routes
• High availability, particularly with GEO satellites
• Robust equipment designed for harsh maritime environments

• High latency, especially with GEO satellites
• Higher equipment and service costs
• Complex installation and maintenance requirements
• Limited speed compared to newer technologies like Starlink

As Starlink continues to expand its satellite constellation and refine its service offerings, it is poised to revolutionize maritime communication. The low latency, high speed, and relatively low cost of Starlink make it an attractive alternative to traditional VSAT systems. While VSAT remains a reliable and established technology, particularly for vessels operating in well-traveled maritime routes, it is increasingly seen as outdated in the face of rapidly advancing LEO satellite technology.

For maritime operators, the choice between Starlink and VSAT will depend on specific needs, such as latency requirements, budget constraints, and coverage area. However, it is clear that Starlink’s innovative approach to satellite internet is pushing the boundaries of what is possible, offering a glimpse into the future of global connectivity. As the maritime industry continues to evolve, the rise of Starlink signals a new era of communication at sea, making VSAT’s long-held dominance increasingly obsolete.

If you have any questions or need assistance, feel free to reach out to our team. We’re here to help!